SQL Server Agent in Express Edition

As you probably know, SQL Server Express doesn’t ship with SQL Server Agent.

This is a known limitation and many people offered alternative solutions to schedule jobs, including windows scheduler, free and commercial third-party applications.

My favourite SQL Server Agent replacement to date is Denny Cherry‘s Standalone SQL Agent, for two reasons:

  1. It uses msdb tables to read job information.
    This means that jobs, schedules and the like can be scripted using the same script you would use in the other editions.
  2. It’s open source and it was started by a person I highly respect.

However, while I still find it a great piece of software, there are a couple of downsides to take into account:

  1. It’s still a beta version and the project hasn’t been very active lately.
  2. There’s no GUI tool to edit jobs or monitor job progress.
  3. It fails to install when UAC is turned on
  4. It’s not 100% compatible with SQL Server 2012
  5. It doesn’t restart automatically when the SQL Server instance starts
  6. It requires sysadmin privileges

The UAC problem during installation is easy to solve: open an elevated command prompt and run the installer msi. Easy peasy.

As far as SQL Server 2012 is concerned, the service fails to start when connected to a 2012 instance. In the ERRORLOG file (the one you find in the Standalone SQL Agent directory, not SQL Server’s) you’ll quickly find the reason of the failure: it can’t create the stored procedure sp_help_job_SSA. I don’t know why this happens: I copied the definition of the stored procedure from a 2008 instance and it worked fine.

If you don’t have a SQL Server 2008 instance available, you can extract the definition of the stored procedure from the source code at CodePlex.

Issue 5) is a bit more tricky to tackle. When the service loses the connection to the target SQL Server instance, it won’t restart automatically and it will remain idle until you cycle the service manually. In the ERRORLOG file you’ll find a message that resembles to this:

Error connecting to SQL Instance.
No connection attempt will be made until Sevice is restarted.

You can overcome this limitation using a startup stored procedure that restarts the service:

USE master

EXEC sp_configure 'advanced',1

EXEC sp_configure 'xp_cmdshell',1

USE master

CREATE PROCEDURE startStandaloneSQLAgent

    EXEC xp_cmdshell 'net stop "Standalone SQL Agent"'
    EXEC xp_cmdshell 'net start "Standalone SQL Agent"'


EXEC sp_procoption @ProcName = 'startStandaloneSQLAgent'
      , @OptionName = 'startup'
      , @OptionValue = 'on';

However, you’ll probably notice that the SQL Server service account does not have sufficient rights to restart the service.

The following PowerShell script grants the SQL Server service account all the rights it needs. In order to run it, you need to download the code available at Rohn Edwards’ blog.

# Change to the display name of your SQL Server Express service
$service = Get-WmiObject win32_service |
	where-object { $_.DisplayName -eq "SQL Server (SQLEXPRESS2008R2)" }

$serviceLogonAccount = $service.StartName

$ServiceAcl = Get-ServiceAcl "Standalone SQL Agent"

# Add an ACE allowing the service user Start and Stop service rights:
$ServiceAcl.AddAccessRule((New-AccessControlEntry -ServiceRights "Start,Stop" -Principal $serviceLogonAccount))

# Apply the modified ACL object to the service:
$ServiceAcl | Set-ServiceAcl

# Confirm the ACE was saved:
Get-ServiceAcl "Standalone SQL Agent" | select -ExpandProperty Access

After running this script from an elevated Powershell instance, you can test whether the startup stored procedure has enough privileges by invoking it manually.

If everything works as expected, you can restart the SQL Server Express instance and the Standalone SQL Agent service will restart as well.

In conclusion, Standalone SQL Agent is a good replacement for SQL Server Agent in Express edition and, while it suffers from some limitations, I still believe it’s the best option available.


Posted on January 23, 2014, in PowerShell, SQL Server and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 3 Comments.

  1. While attempting to get this working on Windows Server 2012 R2 and SQL Server 2014 Express I’ve sort of succeeded to follow your instructions. The stored procedures were not extractable from the source (only one of them was), and I needed to install to a 2005 SQL and export them. I was able install the Standalone in an elevated prompt, and install the ACL powershell scripts (almost successfully – output is here http://pastebin.com/idcx3s9M), and the restart stored procedure installed, but when I restart SQL Server and the SQLStandalone service restarts it still says I dont have permission, and launches the JIT debugger with “An unhandled exception (‘System.Data.SqlClient.SqlException’) occurred in Standalone SQL Agent Service.exe [1208].”

    So, I’m almost there but not quite and would need more help. But thanks for getting me this far!

    • Hi rhodesteve.

      I wondered if you overcame your JIT exception with 2012, or another workaround,

      many thanks, adrian

  2. If you are looking for something that is supported, full functionality and works well with ALL versions of SQL Server including Express take a look at:


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: